Behind me, on the stage, were Balamurali Krishna, N. Ramani and Ravi
Kiran, preparing to perform together for the first, and
(the announcer opined), possibly the last time. In front of me
were 1000 people waiting to hear this trio in concert. I had come
to the center of the front row of Waetjen Auditorium in Cleveland to talk
with the Chief Guest of the Tyagaraja Aradhana, Deputy Ambassador Srinivasan.
Why was he the Chief Guest? Apparently the Indian Ambassador is
regularly invited for this slot. Is this mixing of classical music
and nation-state innocent? Is Srinivasan merely a fan of Tyagaraja?
He told the audience that Clinton and Vajpayee had
signed a mission statement and with Clinton’s visit to India, "we have
really entered a new chapter in Indo-US relations."
It was about this new chapter that I wanted to talk with the Deputy
Ambassador. He told the audience that India was proud
of its 1.3 million Indians in the U.S. "You are the ones that have
been able to convince this nation that you are carriers of
a tradition that is 5000 years old."
Did the Ambassador know that we are interested in the battles of the
present, not of the epic past? I trembled as I began,
"I would like to ask you something about what you said about Indian
and US friendship in connection with Clinton’s visit. Did you know
that he pushed through financing of a dam on the Narmada which the people
of the region oppose?"
"That is not Clinton, that is the World Bank" he said with a smile.
"It is not the World Bank, it is a U.S. company called Ogden
and the deal was signed during Clinton’s visit."
I handed him the leaflet on Ogden, and then told him that an example
of Indian and US friendship was the statement of solidarity which the National
Alliance of People's Movements (NAPM) had extended to the U.S. movement
for democracy and against globalization and corporate control. I
handed him this flyer as well. He said, "we have tried to live without
corporations for 50 years, but we want 10% growth."
He and his wife said many things, to which I responded as best I could.
"Don’t the people get another place to live? Are you
exaggerating?" were some of the classics. If you are one of those
1.3 million Indians who is a mini-ambassador of Indian
culture in the U.S., why not convey your viewpoint to Deputy Ambassador
Srinivasan? He remembered the people outside his
office on March 14, International Day of Action for Rivers and Life.
His wife also seemed to be curious. Ask them to call
Ogden, and see that this new chapter does not get off on the wrong
start.
I could also have told him about Indian government’s murder of Indian
Army Colonel Pratap Save, who was only trying to save
the land in Gujarat, as part of Kinnara Bachao Sangarsh Samiti, nonviolently
resisting the entry of a Multinational Corporate
Port.
But the concert was about to begin. We should have seen the warning
signals. The three had never practiced, Balamurali
Krishna had not touched a violin in 2 years, but just came to the stage
and picked it up. Sure we are impressed by his
genius, and we are all in favour of experiment and improvisation, but
need we do it in the Saturday night slot of a week-long festival?
The first hour was a drag. The passionless theatrics of Ravi Kiran
came off as mere machismo.
The three crescendoed well. When the applause subsided I saw that
the front and center seats were empty. I turned around to
look for the Ambassador and his wife; I saw dozens of people exiting.
Next came a bhajan to wind down and a tillana
to finish. A hall that normally pulsates till midnight on the
eve of Easter Sunday was empty by 10 pm.
So much the better for Sanjay Subramaniam. The Sunday morning
slot often suffers from the lateness of the previous night, and
sometimes also from the clock change, should Easter fall at the end
of March. This time the hall was packed early in the morning.
I enjoyed his highly expressive hand and head movements, at times churning
buttermilk, pulling taffy, darting to catch runaway pieces of paper.
Previous years concerts have riveted me to my seat -- that quality was
entirely absent from this years’ featured artists concerts. Of course
major treats were in store later in the week, including R. Jayanti (Veena),
S. Sowmya, and T. N. Seshagopalan. In the individual singing, however,
you could not even go out for water without missing something. A
spring of surprise talent rose in the under-10 age group. The amateur
sessions simply get better year after year, and this is only my fourth
year. I can only imagine the satisfaction of someone like T. Temple
Tuttle, who has seen this festival over 20 years. He came to greet
the audience, though he is seriously ill. "One of the first concepts
I ever learned about India is the extended family, and that brings with
it both great privileges and responsibilities. I simply had to be
here today." The Aradhana Committee declared that from now on the
Children and Youth Competitions would be named "Tom Tuttle’s Children and
Youth Competition."
How will these youth assume their role as the "carriers of culture?"
Only in the Amateur section of the festival do we see women and men, boys
and girls cheerfully and mutually-supportively sharing the stage, thinking
of nothing more than music and devotion. Vests were popular with
the boys and the half-sari had made a comeback among the teenage girls.
After the morning bhajans and pancharatna kiratanas, we were never to see
so many women on stage again. The old-boy quality of the festival
came out most in the awards ceremony. Only one award went to a woman
(for her volunteer services) and she effaced herself while accepting it.
The men donned the shawls, referred to their previous awards, congratulated
one another. CDs were released and accepted. However when a
young man from Cleveland offered his CD to Ravi Kiran, the Artist could
barely manage a perfunctory blessing. How different from the exuberant
Ravi Kiran we saw in Cleveland six years ago.
Why in such small age increments do we see the unkindness and social
inequalities creeping in? Will the same children we see today inherit
the same gender prejudices ten years from now? Or even sooner?
What "new chapter" in Indo-US relations will the youth of today inaugurate
in their turn?
The Ambassador's message of U.S. spending being good for India is one
this audience is ready and willing to receive. Earlier we saw digital
infotech employed to standardize certain themes of the epic Ramayana, in
order to make the story available "without language barriers" meaning,
in the first world's first language. The salesman explained that
wherever there was a difference between their "CD Ram" and what they called
"cultural belief" abut the epic, they justified their choice with reference
to Valmiki. Presumably, the sage saved his files.
Not all the discrimination was in the hands of the organizers.
Out of 57 visa applications for artists, 53 were granted and 4 were rejected.
These four were the nadaswaram troupe, including the only 2 artists of
Muslim background invited for the festival.
Early comers to the premeire show of Annamayya dance drama got a treat
since the musicians tested sound to old standards like "ninnu kori."
As no programs were given nor were artists introduced, I know no names.
Here again are state markings on the life of 15th century poet Annamacharya.
Not only are the costumes of the dancers in the invocatory "Surya Namaskaram"
orange and green, but the shadows cast by Annamacharya are also orange
and green (at a 30 degree angle).
Kudos to the child Annamayya who not only performed vigorous steps in
a lengthy dhoti (while the more subdued first scene was done in the abbreviated
lungi), but managed to pick herself up after a fall, and still maintain
her expressions, including the half-closed eyes of bhakti.
Annamayya's youth and marriage are followed by a second marraige.
Nothing like a woman narrator explaining, "believing it to be God's will,
Annamayya marries Akalamma." Skepticism rumbled through the audience.
For a show that was advertised with only two words, "Sold Out," at least
a quarter of the seats were empty. It opened with a series of comparisons
between Annamayya and Balamurali Krishna. Both legends in their own
time, devotees of Narayana, they even shared a birth star. Balamurali
fans will turn out for this, and he certainly stands and delivers.
I can still feel my heart fluttering at his "Jo Acyutananda." I only
wish he sang the whole song. The best dancer had all the non-characters
... the minor gods, demons, animals, the bow. He also played a harijan
who was barred from the worship of god, prompting Annamayya's song "Brahmam
Okkate." (god is one). All this fair-mindedness doesn't keep
the hindu nationalism out of the drama though. The narrator tells
us that the drama uses many dance forms, including yaksha gana, odissi,
mohini attam and kathak. (Watch carefully, because while they add
a nice touch, most of these last barely a minute. The sole kathak
dancer is brought back at the end to figure as the Muslim invader, destroying
temples and sending Annamayya on a quest where he has a vision of Hanuman.
Review of Cleveland Tyagaraja Aradhana, 22-23 April 2000